I'm such a sucker for good design.
The main characteristics I was looking for was that the theme should be simple, elegant and functional. And Divya was bang on target.
Three months later, the theme is live. I got eager, so it's not quite done yet. I'm still tweaking things all over the place.
Update: As always, when there is something new, there will be new glitches. Commenting was broken but it should be working now. Thanks to Manish for alerting me.